For a long time, I hesitated to write about PDA in school.
Not because it isn’t important — but because so much of what’s already out there doesn’t sit right with me. It talks about behaviour, compliance, or how to reduce demand avoidance, without stopping to ask the more uncomfortable question: what is school actually asking of this nervous system in the first place?
When I work with PDA-profiled children and teenagers, and with adults who once were those children, the same pattern shows up again and again. The issue isn’t learning. It isn’t intelligence. And it certainly isn’t unwillingness.
It’s safety.
The invisible weight of school
School is full of demands that are rarely named as demands.
Sitting still. Starting on cue. Showing your working. Transitioning when the bell goes. Being watched. Being assessed. Knowing that someone, somewhere, is tracking your effort, your tone, your compliance.
For many students, those expectations fade into the background.
For a student with a PDA profile, they don’t.
They stack.
Each demand lands in the body as pressure, not motivational pressure, but threat. The nervous system starts scanning for escape routes long before the lesson itself has really begun.
By the time adults notice refusal, shutdown, humour, distraction, or emotional escalation, the student is already well past their limit.
“But they can do it at home”
This comes up constantly.
And on the surface, it makes sense — until you understand PDA.
Home and school don’t place the same demands on a nervous system. The relational stakes are different. The power dynamics are different. The cost of getting something wrong is usually lower. There’s often more control over timing, pacing, and how visible effort is allowed to be.
At school, everything is public.
Effort is visible. Mistakes are visible. Avoidance is visible. Autonomy is thin. Even praise can feel risky, because it often carries expectations, and expectations are still demands.
So the student avoids.
Not because they don’t care, but because caring costs too much.
When avoidance is doing a job
Avoidance is usually treated as the problem.
But for students with PDA, avoidance is often the solution their nervous system has found to stay regulated.
Avoidance reduces exposure. It reduces evaluation. It reduces the feeling of being trapped. Sometimes, it’s the only way a student knows how to preserve dignity in a system that constantly asks for performance.
When we try to remove avoidance without understanding what it’s protecting the student from, things tend to unravel. Distress escalates. Behaviour intensifies. Trust wears thin. School becomes a site of conflict rather than a place of learning.
And the student learns something quietly but powerfully: this place is not safe for me.
What changes when we think about safety instead
When PDA is viewed through a behaviour lens, responses tend to focus on compliance.
When it’s viewed through a safety lens, everything shifts.
The question stops being: “Why won’t they do this?”
And becomes: “What is this situation demanding from their nervous system?”
Sometimes it’s speed. Sometimes it’s visibility. Sometimes it’s emotional exposure. Sometimes it’s a loss of choice. Often, it’s several of these things at once.
Why this matters long after school
I work with too many adults who carry deep shame from school experiences that never made sense to them at the time.
They were labelled lazy. Manipulative. Capable but unwilling. Difficult.
In reality, they were overwhelmed.
When schools understand PDA, we don’t just support the student in front of us. We interrupt a longer trajectory — one that leads to burnout, disengagement, and chronic self-blame.
We create space for learning that doesn’t require sacrificing safety to access it.
A different way forward
Supporting PDA in school isn’t about removing expectations altogether. It’s about reducing unnecessary pressure, restoring autonomy where possible, and putting the relationship ahead of compliance.
It’s about recognising that learning simply doesn’t happen while a nervous system is in survival mode.
And it’s about understanding that demand avoidance isn’t the enemy, it’s information.
If we’re willing to listen.
I spend a lot of time talking with teachers, school leaders, and families who are trying to make sense of this, often after things have already become hard.
I have a self-paced 2.5-hour online course on PDA in School that goes deeper into what this looks like in real classrooms, why traditional approaches so often backfire, and how schools can respond in ways that reduce distress rather than escalate it.
This course includes a certificate with 2.5 professional development hours. You can find more details and enrol here.
When School Feels Impossible: Understanding and Supporting PDA Students
A free guide for teachers, education staff and families, with an “At a glance” summary, practical strategies, reflection space and a classroom planning checklist.
About Barb Cook, M.Aut.(Ed), Dip.HSc.(Nut)
Barb Cook is a Registered Developmental Educator, Integrative Nutritionist, Adult ADHD Coach and Accredited Australian Athletics Coach. She brings together clinical practice, research, and lived experience as an autistic, ADHD, and dyslexic adult diagnosed in midlife.
Barb holds a Master of Autism (Education) degree from the University of Wollongong and has worked as a researcher and co-project lead in the areas of self-determination and self-advocacy for autistic adults. She is an internationally recognised speaker, writer, and advocate, and the bestselling co-author of Spectrum Women: Walking to the Beat of Autism, The Autism and Neurodiversity Self‑Advocacy Handbook, and Planning Your Career Through Intense Interests.
Her work focuses on supporting autistic, ADHD, and AuDHD people across the lifespan through neurodiversity-affirming, practical, and holistic approaches that prioritise wellbeing, capacity, and sustainability.
-
Spectrum Women: Walking to the Beat of Autism | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback to Pinterest (opens in a new window)
Spectrum Women: Walking to the Beat of Autism | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback
$51.99Original price was: $51.99.$39.99Current price is: $39.99. Add to cart -
The Autism and Neurodiversity Self Advocacy Handbook | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback to Pinterest (opens in a new window)
The Autism and Neurodiversity Self Advocacy Handbook | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback
$48.99Original price was: $48.99.$38.99Current price is: $38.99. Add to cart -
Planning Your Career Through Intense Interests: A Guide for Autistic People | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback to Pinterest (opens in a new window)
Planning Your Career Through Intense Interests: A Guide for Autistic People | Signed by Barb Cook | Paperback
$42.99Original price was: $42.99.$32.99Current price is: $32.99. Add to cart -
Spectrum Women: Autism and Parenting
$48.99Original price was: $48.99.$35.99Current price is: $35.99. Add to cart -
The Year I Met My Brain | Book
$35.00Original price was: $35.00.$25.00Current price is: $25.00. Add to cart -
The ADHD Brain Buddy: A Practical Toolkit for Adults Navigating a More ADHD-Friendly Life | Book to Pinterest (opens in a new window)
The ADHD Brain Buddy: A Practical Toolkit for Adults Navigating a More ADHD-Friendly Life | Book
$34.99Original price was: $34.99.$27.99Current price is: $27.99. Add to cart







